Delhi High Court Directs Medha Patkar to Approach Trial Court for Sentence Postponement in Defamation Case
The Delhi High Court on April 22 directed activist Medha Patkar to seek relief from the trial court regarding her sentencing in the defamation case filed by Delhi LG VK Saxena.
Key Highlights:
Delhi High Court on April 22, 2025, advised activist Medha Patkar to move the trial court if she wished to seek postponement of her sentencing in the defamation case filed by Delhi Lieutenant Governor VK Saxena. The bench clarified that it is the trial court’s prerogative to take a decision on such matters.
The directive came in response to an application by Patkar’s legal team requesting the High Court to postpone the sentencing date, citing her health and logistical constraints in appearing in person.
Background: Longstanding Legal Battle Between VK Saxena and Medha Patkar
The case dates back to 2001, when VK Saxena—then the head of the National Council for Civil Liberties—filed a defamation suit against Medha Patkar. The charges were based on allegations that Patkar had made derogatory and baseless claims against him in a press release issued during that period.
After years of proceedings, the trial court in Delhi had, in July 2024, sentenced Patkar to five months of simple imprisonment and directed her to pay ₹10 lakh in compensation to Saxena. However, the sentencing was suspended for 30 days to allow her legal recourse through appeals.
Delhi High Court’s View on Jurisdiction
Hearing Patkar’s request for postponement, the Delhi High Court observed that it was procedurally incorrect to approach the High Court directly for sentence rescheduling. Justice emphasized:
“Applications for deferral of sentencing should be submitted before the trial court. It is that court’s domain to assess the grounds and circumstances.”
The High Court refrained from passing any interim order and asked Patkar’s counsel to file the application with the appropriate trial bench.
Medha Patkar’s Argument for Sentence Postponement
Patkar’s legal counsel cited the following grounds for seeking postponement:
- 👩⚕️ Health-related complications preventing her from traveling
- 🏛️ Ongoing preparations for appeal in the higher judiciary
- ⏳ Need for adequate time to prepare for the sentencing hearing
The High Court did not reject the plea outright but reinforced the importance of hierarchical judicial procedure, instructing Patkar to move her application in the court where the matter was originally tried.
What This Means for Medha Patkar and the Case
- ⚖️ The trial court will now decide whether to allow a postponement or proceed with sentencing
- 📰 The case continues to draw public attention, given Patkar’s prominence in environmental and human rights activism
- 👨⚖️ VK Saxena’s position as Delhi LG adds political weight to the ongoing legal narrative
How to Take Action
- 📃 Activists and public figures facing legal battles must ensure all jurisdictional procedures are followed
- 🏛️ Observers may view this as a test case on whether civil defamation can effectively be used against public criticism
- 🧾 Legal scholars may debate the balance between freedom of expression and reputational protection
Who Will Be Affected
- ⚖️ Medha Patkar, who now faces potential jail time pending the outcome of appeals
- 🧑⚖️ Trial court authorities, who must now evaluate a high-profile postponement request
- 🧑💼 Legal professionals and activists, closely watching this case as precedent for political defamation claims
Delhi High Court’s Stance Reinforces Procedural Discipline
The Delhi High Court has once again reiterated the importance of respecting judicial hierarchy and proper forum usage. As the case returns to the trial court, all eyes remain on how it will weigh the activist’s request, especially amid rising discourse around defamation, dissent, and judicial independence in India.
Stay updated with the latest from Hindustan Herald — your trusted source for
Politics, Business, Sports, Entertainment, Lifestyle, Breaking News, and More.
📲 Follow us on Facebook, Instagram, Twitter, LinkedIn, and YouTube
🔔 Join our Telegram channel @hindustanherald for real-time news alerts.
